Veteran-Owned Centerville Insurance Agency
Centerville Insurance Agency Greg Fay Insurance is well known for helping families and businesses throughout Centerville, Miamisburg, Springboro, Kettering, Waynesville, and Greater Dayton protect what matters most. As a proud veteran-owned insurance agency, Greg Fay and his team are built on service, integrity, community involvement, and personalized protection plans tailored to your needs.
Insurance can be complicated, and when it comes to protecting your home, vehicles, business, and family, you deserve more than an 800 number or offshore call center.
Our local Centerville insurance agents take the time to meet with you personally, listen to your concerns, explain your options, and help develop a dependable coverage plan designed for life’s unexpected events.
Meet Greg, Agent at Greg Fay Insurance of Centerville, Ohio:
As your personal insurance agent, it is my mission to help you develop the right plans to meet your insurance needs.
Through dedication, knowledge, and a tireless work ethic, I will be the insurance agent whom my customers want to send their friends and families to. I will strive to protect my clients’ assets, knowing how hard they have worked to acquire them and increase their net worth.
Along with being your personal insurance agent, I have been a successful local businessman for more than 20 years. I am a veteran of the United States Army, where I proudly served this country for six years before being Honorably Discharged in 1990.
I have been active as a teaching leader in the youth ministry of South Brook Christian Church for almost 15 years. I have sat on the board and served as a committee president for the most robust and energetic service organization in the world, Centerville Noon Optimist and I have been a youth coach in Football, Basketball, and Baseball in the Centerville area for almost 10 years.
My wife, Stacey Cummins Hinkle Fay, and six (yes I said 6) children have lived here in Centerville for more than 20 years. I care so deeply for this community and the local businesses that operate here that I started the Centerville Community-Hosted by Greg Fay Insurance – a Veteran Owned Agency 6 years ago so that local Centerville, Ohio businesses and residents could connect via organic recommendations. The Facebook community page has taken off so well that it is now used for our local Centerville school, government, and charity / non-profit announcements also.
We truly look at each member of our community as a neighbor and friend and we would love to take care of each one as a valued client.
I have life insurance because I love my family. Contact me to schedule an appointment to review your family’s protection today!
We Offer a Broad Range of Personal and Business Insurance Solutions Tailored to your Needs
We have a stable of well-known Insurance companies that we can use to protect the things that mean the most to you.
A Deep Commitment to the Centerville Community
Greg Fay has been a successful local businessman for more than 20 years. He and his wife, Stacey Cummins Hinkle Fay, have proudly raised their six children in Centerville and continue to stay actively involved throughout the local community.
Greg has dedicated years of service to local Centerville organizations and youth programs throughout the area, including:
- Youth coaching in football, basketball, and baseball
- Leadership roles within SouthBrook Christian Church
- Service with the Centerville Noon Optimist organization
- Community outreach and local business support initiatives
Greg also created the “Centerville Community – Hosted by Expert Protection Services” Facebook group to help local businesses, residents, schools, charities, and nonprofit organizations connect through positive community engagement and recommendations.
With Greg Fay of Expert Protection Services Agency, his clients are viewed as neighbors and friends — not transactions.
Contact Greg Fay in Centerville Ohio


Families throughout Centerville and Greater Dayton trust Greg Fay because they know they are working with a local veteran-owned insurance agency that genuinely cares about the community. Our exceptional reviews prove that!
Contact Greg Fay of Expert Protection Services Agency for trusted local insurance guidance backed by service, integrity, and community commitment. Greg Fay proudly helps families and businesses throughout Centerville and Greater Dayton protect what matters most with personalized home, auto, life, and business insurance solutions.
Whether you are protecting your home, vehicle, business, or family’s future, Greg Fay and his team are committed to helping you find dependable coverage with personal service you can trust. Get a quote online to get started.
Ask for Greg Fay personally when you call and schedule a personalized insurance review today.
Ministries We Actively Support













